Re: canon (was: Alcatraz Class Prison Transport)

Part of thread: Re: canon (was: Alcatraz Class Prison Transport) · 1 reply ↳ In reply to Re: canon (was: Alcatraz Class Prison Transport) — DED Re: canon (was: Alcatraz Class Prison Transport) — Master Uxi
>
> Well, Dave. You of all people should be quite familiar with the rabidity
> of Traveller fans, especially the older players. I know I've said this
> before on some messageboard, but the uncompromising and inflexible
> nature that some of these people have is tantamount to fanatical
> religious behavior, hence the adoption of the use of the word "canon."

Which is exactly why I dislike the term, because it gives tacit approval
to, or encourages that kind of thinking. When I started using it, it was
ironic, poking fun at the idea that, "geez, guys, you'd think this was a
religion, it's only a game." Once I started noticing that people were
using it with a straight face, encouraging that quasi-religious approach,
I stopped enjoying the term.

> The thought that designers would alter their beloved Classic Traveller
> is blasphemy. I'd say the reaction towards TNE was borderline Jihad.
> Only Archbishop Marc Miller is allowed to change the Traveller scripture.

When TNE came out, Traveller belonged to GDW, and Marc didn't work there
anymore, and somehow we had promised a new edition. Kind of sucked to be
us, huh?